iprecht.comhorak law firm
Home / Legal updates

Hansson and compensation for plant variety infringement

In C-481/14 the Court of Justice distinguished reasonable compensation for unauthorised use of a protected variety from compensation for further damage.

In C-481/14 the Court of Justice distinguished reasonable compensation for unauthorised use of a protected variety from compensation for further damage. A royalty-based calculation needs a factual basis. Separate evidence of production, sale and additional loss before deciding what to claim.

Practical examples

Nursery propagates protected plants

Compare quantities with authorised stock purchases and propagation records.

Licence rate in dispute

Check whether comparable licences cover the same acts, territory and period.

Breeder alleges additional losses

Identify the separate loss and evidence supporting causation.

Several parties handled the plants

Distinguish propagation from later distribution and record the role of each business.

Official reference