Brompton Bicycle and copyright in functional shapes
In C-833/18 the Court of Justice considered the shape of a folding bicycle.
In C-833/18 the Court of Justice considered the shape of a folding bicycle. A useful product can qualify for copyright where its form expresses free and creative choices. Where technical considerations leave no room for creative freedom, originality cannot be based on those constraints. The design record can therefore matter as much as the finished product.
Practical examples
Folding mechanism
Separate the geometry demanded by the mechanism from choices about its external shape.
Competing prototype
Preserve dated sketches and the constraints under which the designer worked.
Expired patent
Read the patent to identify technical aims, then assess the claimed copyright features separately.
Replacement component
Compare functional interfaces with freely chosen visual details before deciding how to respond.