iprecht.comhorak law firm
Home / Legal updates

Pelham: assessing pastiche before releasing a sampled recording

In C-590/23, a reference from Germany’s Federal Court of Justice, the Court of Justice examined the EU concept of pastiche in a dispute over sampling.

In C-590/23, a reference from Germany’s Federal Court of Justice, the Court of Justice examined the EU concept of pastiche in a dispute over sampling. The precise use and its relationship with the earlier work matter. Producers should preserve the source recording, identify the excerpt and document the artistic use before deciding whether to seek clearance.

Practical examples

Advertising agency uses a loop

Identify both the composition and recording and check whether the commercial brief supports the proposed use.

Producer describes a track as a tribute

Document how the finished piece engages with the earlier material.

Label acquires a master

Ask for the sample inventory, permissions and any exception analysis before accepting warranties.

Distributor receives a complaint

Preserve the release version and compare it with the identified source before responding.

Official reference